Part of the Responsible Subversives Network Beta

Equipping future generations to shape a better world Who are we?

Back to top

Overschooled Feedback

Selected reviews of Overschooled but Undereducated external-link

Reviews of John Abbott and Heather McTaggart’s book Overschooled but Undereducated can be viewed here.

Lorenzo McLellan

November 18, 2010

A truly remarkable triumph. John Abbott has managed to set to words the seemingly inexplicable malaise which haunts the educational system today in Britain. ‘Overschooled and Undereducated’ provides an invaluable insight into a staggering range of interdisciplinary theory and research to explain precisely why schools aren’t working as they should be, and could be. The […]

Ben England, Head of Music

May 6, 2010

The thing that helped most was the clear, reasonable and perfectly logical explanation of why I was a miserable sod from the age of about 13 until I became a teacher at 22.

Readers responses to Michael Shaw’s review of “Over-schooled but Undereducated”, TES, 22nd January 2010

Janet M. Lawley, former headmistress and an advocate for children. What a pity that Michael Shaw was unfamiliar with the concept of cognitive apprenticeship as a model of learning and assumed that it was the same as traditional apprenticeship. It is almost two decades since Collins, Brown and Hollum published their thesis, “Cognitive Apprenticeship – […]

The Right Reverend Peter B. Price, The Bishop of Bath and Wells

February 17, 2009

John Abbott has provided an accessible and challenging book that provides valuable insights into adolescents and the need for an appropriate approach to their educational development for adult life and responsibility.

Pete Mountstephen, Headteacher

February 17, 2009

Primary School Headteacher, and currently Chairman of the Primary Heads Association, England

Chris Kington, Chris Kington Publishing, Optimus Education

February 17, 2009

Overschooled but Undereducated is a truly inspiring read and a worthwhile publication. It surpasses Abbott & Ryan: The Unfinished Revolution, 2000 which is an accolade indeed. The message flows through so powerfully to the end – I have thoroughly enjoyed it. But what is truly exciting about this – and I am aware this is […]

Jeff Hopkins, Superintendent of Schools, District 64, Canada

February 17, 2009

Overschooled and Undereducated is more than just another book that breathes the usual heavy sigh of despair in reaction to much of the western world’s education system today. Rather, the book provides a rich history that outlines significant twists and turns in the path leading to our current system and describes in great detail the […]

Paul Fisher, Teacher

February 17, 2009

Overschooled but Undereducated begins with the fable of a deer whose evolution hasn’t adapted it to cope with car headlights. “We too are transfixed by the lights which are about to destroy us,” is the anthropomorphic moral at the opening of a book that develops into a survival guide posited on a revamped education system. […]

Nigel Coren, Headteacher

February 17, 2009

Former Primary School Headmaster, Sussex

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.